UIViewController Custom Back Button Problem

If you want your apps to have an identity of their own, you should put some time into adjusting the default appearance, such as fonts and standard iconography.

One thing that may be a bit tricky, is to replace the default back button with a custom one. It is a very simple thing to achieve, but in one app of mine, I just could not get it to work.

The process is very simple. In viewDidLoad, I just called some code that should replace the standard back button with a nice, custom arrow. It took me like five minutes to get everything up and running, including importing the image files to the project, do 1000 push-ups and watch some epic rap battles on YouTube.

However, when I decided to revisit an old app of mine and add this feature to it as well, I could not get it to work. The following kept me busy a whole evening:

  • The app navigates to a table view controller from another table view controller
  • If I call the back button replacement code in viewDidLoad, the original back button doesn’t disappear. Instead, the new back button is added on top of it.
  • If I call the code in viewWillAppear or viewDidAppear, nothing happens… since these methods are never called (???)

I tried replacing the clean code I had with timers and other horrible hacks, but nothing worked (luckily, I might add, since that is NOT the way you should solve this problem). I then found this post, which suggests adding a fake back button, then remove it when replacing the real back button with a custom one, like this:

self.navigationItem.leftBarButtonItem = [[UIBarButtonItem alloc] initWithCustomView:[[UIView alloc] init]];
self.navigationItem.leftBarButtonItem = nil;
self.navigationItem.hidesBackButton = YES;
self.navigationItem.leftBarButtonItem = /* Set your bar button here */;

This solution is just strange, and should not work either…which it didn’t. The original back button shows briefly, before it disappears. Nothing is solved.

I am still stuck with this problem, with no idea what is causing it. I don’t see this strange behavior in my other apps, even when adding the same original code. I even tried recreating the view controllers in a new project, with the same set of base classes and view lifecycle events, and it works just fine.

Any ideas, world?